中文

Four Pillars — Build Your Own Two First: Truth → Excellence → Courage → Justice

JIAHON Group · JIAHON Think Tank perspective. Published by JIAHON Think Tank | Written by Marcus (Senior Vice President) | 6 September 2026 | jiahon.com.tw

Effort does not make success certain; that is a statement about a single event. Without effort there will certainly be no success; that is a statement about a lifetime. When the wider environment can’t be changed, the order a person should follow is: first face yourself and the harshest facts honestly, then raise the probability of each attempt through effort; once you have the capability, amplify courage and justice. This article starts from the four pillars in Gad Saad’s Suicidal Empathy, and it is about the individual, not society.

In brief

Effort does not make success certain in any single attempt; the absence of effort makes failure over a lifetime certain. That distinction — a single try is a dice roll, a life is a probability — is the spine of this note. Gad Saad’s 2026 book describes a society standing on four pillars (justice, courage, truth, excellence) and how misdirected empathy saws each one down. We borrow the pillars but change the order, because two of them belong to society and two belong to the individual.

The individual’s order is truth → excellence → courage → justice: first face yourself and the harshest facts of your environment; then commit to becoming better, which raises the probability of each attempt; roll the dice many times so the law of large numbers can work; and only once capability has grown, amplify courage and justice within an expanding circle. We close with what this order means for a mid-stream industrial supplier.

1. A single attempt is a dice roll; a life is a probability

One die in the air is a single attempt; the whole table of dice is a lifetime.

Effort does not make success certain — that is about a single event. Without effort there will certainly be no success — that is about your whole life.

Many people today have little resilience. After one setback, they start following the common explanations: there are few jobs, more people fail than succeed, success is luck rather than ability, the environment is bad. Each of these is partly true, which is why they are so handy — they let a person explain away failure without honestly looking at themselves.

But these explanations leave one thing out: success or failure in a single attempt is a dice roll; success or failure over a life is a probability. What you can change is not the dice but the probability. This article is about that order — what a person should do first, and what next, when the wider environment can’t be changed.

2. Introduction: one book, four pillars

The starting point is a book. Evolutionary psychologist Gad Saad’s Suicidal Empathy: Dying to Be Kind (2026) is about how Western society is being dragged down by runaway kindness. His argument in one sentence: empathy is a virtue, but aimed at the wrong target or at the wrong intensity, it becomes the hand that saws through the pillars. A society stands on four pillars — justice (wrongdoers are punished), courage (those who stand in front are respected), truth (true things can be said) and excellence (those who don’t measure up are eliminated). Each requires someone to have a hard time, and runaway empathy, every time it sees someone having a hard time, goes to saw at that pillar.

The book’s cases are clear enough: a man who subdued someone threatening subway passengers was prosecuted, while nobody asked about the passengers he saved; medical education guidelines put social justice ahead of professional competence; a fire department official, asked what happens if a female firefighter can’t carry a casualty, answered that the person had gone to the wrong place; offenders are treated as blank slates, with every stain painted on by society. The way to tell whether something has run out of control fits in one sentence: look at which way the empathy flows — toward the victim or the perpetrator, toward those who follow the rules or those who exploit the loopholes.

The book is a good introduction. But it is about society, and this article is about people — because a society’s pillars can’t be raised by one person, and nobody can raise a person’s pillars for them.

3. Two belong to society, two belong to you

The four pillars are not the same kind of thing. Justice and courage are society’s pillars: they need institutions, precedents and many people together; one person can’t move them. Truth and excellence are your own pillars: they need nobody’s approval, and you can start today.

So the order is not the book’s order but the individual’s: truth first, then excellence; once you have more resources and capability, amplify courage and justice. All four are needed, but raise your own two first.

4. The first pillar: truth

Those who see it treat it as terrain — go around it, or use it.

The first pillar has to be truth. It has two directions.

Facing yourself honestly. How far your ability reaches, why the last attempt failed, what was luck and what was ability. Nobody can do this for you, and nobody can see it, so it is easy to skip. The cost of skipping it is that you keep rolling the dice at the same probability and blame every result on the environment.

It looks a lot like complaining — both talk about your own wounds — but it points the opposite way: looking inward is truth; crying outward is performance and defense. The first changes the probability of the next attempt; the second only earns sympathy.

Seeing the environment honestly. The more glaring and the harsher it sounds, the more you need to look. Systems get gamed — unemployment benefits have tricks only insiders know; when a law changes, hesitation on the front line doesn’t necessarily change with it; standards get lowered because some people can’t meet them. You mostly can’t change these things. But seeing them makes a big difference: those who don’t see them take them as proof that “the environment is bad” and stay where they are; those who see them treat them as terrain — go around it, or use it.

Truth has one enemy: comfort. Avoiding harsh facts feels better now, and the bill comes later. It is the same mechanism the book describes in society — the pleasure is now, the cost is in the future. The only difference: society’s cost falls on others, the individual’s on themselves. So the individual has even less reason than society to look away.

5. The second pillar: excellence

Effort changes the probability, not the outcome: that cluster in the bullseye comes from shooting more times.

Once you face things honestly, one thing follows naturally: you want to get better. That is the drive for excellence. It isn’t “I want to succeed”; it is “through my own effort, I want the next attempt’s probability to be higher than this one’s”. The two sentences are very different, because the first bets the outcome on the dice and the second bets it on yourself.

Effort changes the probability, not the outcome. Going out to negotiate a deal, effort can raise the chance of closing from 30% to 80%. But 80% isn’t 100% — go out once and there is still a 20% chance of coming back empty-handed. That is a single event, a dice roll.

A life is something else. Negotiate a hundred times: at 30% you win thirty deals, at 80% you win eighty. That isn’t luck; it is probability times attempts — the law of large numbers. So someone who accepts that luck exists should do two things: raise the probability, then roll more times. Those who give up do neither.

Table 1: The same person at three probabilities — no visible difference in a single attempt, three times the difference over a lifetime.

Probability of success per attemptProbability of coming back empty-handedAt least one success in 10 attemptsExpected deals in 100 attempts
30% (unprepared)70%97.2%30
50%50%99.9%50
80% (well prepared)20%close to 100%80

“When you see a worthy person, think of becoming equal to them; when you see an unworthy one, examine yourself.” This line from the Analects describes an upward mechanism, and both halves are needed.

Seeing the worthy and wanting to equal them: on seeing someone successful, the fashionable first reaction is “they were just lucky” or “survivorship bias”. Half of that is true — luck does play a part. But going from “luck played a part” to “so effort isn’t needed” is a leap. The right reaction is to look at what they did right and what could raise your own probability, then learn it.

Seeing the unworthy and examining yourself: on seeing failure — including your own — look back at where your probability leaked. Not self-blame; an audit.

Today’s common wisdom has dismantled both halves: see the worthy and don’t try to equal them, see the unworthy and don’t examine yourself, leaving “you’re not perfect and neither am I, so you can’t teach me”. Everyone stays where they are, with no upward force.

6. When a setback comes, two paths

The same setback, two paths — one loops back to the start, the other goes up.

Resilience isn’t endurance; it is whether you treat a failure as information. The same setback offers two paths.

What is frightening about the upper path is not that it makes people fail, but that it makes them more and more sure they are right: every identical result becomes fresh proof that “the environment is bad”. The lower path is no easier — facing yourself honestly is never easy — but it is the one path that accumulates.

7. The third and fourth pillars: courage and justice, amplified once you have the capability

Whoever stands in front must first stand firm.

The order has its reasons: courage without capability is recklessness; justice without capability is a slogan. When a capable person says no, others listen; when a capable person rewards and punishes fairly, others follow. So these two pillars aren’t unimportant — they need the first two to be standing firm before they have anything to rest on.

Courage — start within your own scope. Dare to say this lot can’t ship, dare to tell the customer where the risk is, dare to stand in front. The scope widens with capability — first your own work, then the team, then the company, then beyond. The book’s cases of people who stood in front and were then blamed describe society’s pillar falling; but whether a person can stand in front within their own scope has nothing to do with society.

Justice — rewards and penalties that match the person. Which way empathy flows: start by looking at your own team. If the person who made the mistake is comforted and the one who carried the load goes unnoticed, the one who carries will stop carrying. At the level of society the principle is the same, but first use “truth” to see the facts clearly. For example, any discussion of punishment runs into wrongful convictions, and Taiwan has carried one out (Chiang Kuo-ching, executed in 1997, acquitted in 2011); but “the probability of a wrong verdict isn’t zero” leads to “the procedure must be rigorous enough”, not “there must be none” — the probabilities of surgical misdiagnosis and air crashes aren’t zero either, and society hasn’t stopped because of them. In 1997 there was no DNA matching and no CCTV on every street; today “a rigorous enough procedure” is achievable. First see clearly what the facts can lead to, then take a position — that is truth applied to justice.

Amplifying is a cumulative process. Only when a person’s own pillars stand firm do they have the strength to raise society’s. Those who do it the other way round — shouting about society’s two pillars before raising their own — usually shout loudly, because shouting is easier than building.

8. The book’s role

In this article, Suicidal Empathy is the introduction, not the main subject. Its value is a handy framework of four pillars and a set of clear cases. Its weakness deserves a sentence too: it looks for the disease in one direction only — miscalibrated empathy is a problem of human nature, not of one political position; a theory that always finds the disease in its opponents may be measuring partisanship. The reading is simple: take the framework, take the cases, discount the sense of doom.

And it gives a diagnosis for society, not a prescription for the individual. The individual’s prescription is this article’s order: truth, excellence, courage, justice.

9. What this means for a mid-stream supply chain company

A mid-stream company is like a person: the wider environment can’t be changed; what can be changed is its own two pillars.

A mid-stream company — caught between upstream makers and downstream customers, living on standards and credibility — is like a person: the wider environment can’t be changed; what it can change is its own two pillars. The order is the same.

Truth — look at your own numbers first. Yield, delivery, the real reasons customers leave, why the last order was lost. If an ugly quality report is buried “so as not to hurt morale”, what gets cut is the ability to correct, and things only get uglier. Look at the harsh things first.

Excellence — raise the probability of every attempt. Not every order has to be won; the question is how many of a hundred. Check the specification once more before quoting, prepare one more comparison, confirm the customer’s real need once more — each of these pushes 30% toward 80%. Resilience applies to companies in the same words: losing one order isn’t information; losing ten is.

Courage — dare to say no. When a customer asks for a specification you can’t meet, saying “after evaluation, this is where the engineering risk lies” is better for both sides than taking it on and having it go wrong. Engineers willing to say “this lot can’t ship” should be recognized, not blamed.

Justice — rewards and penalties that match. If late suppliers keep getting orders and on-time ones get no more, the on-time supplier leaves first. Goodwill — free samples, priority scheduling, extended payment terms — should each be tied to reciprocity: keep giving where it comes back, withdraw where it doesn’t.

When the wider environment can’t be changed, change yourself first. Effort not making success certain is about a single attempt; no effort making failure certain is about a lifetime. Face yourself and the harsh facts honestly, raise the probability of each attempt through effort, roll the dice more times, and let the law of large numbers work for you.

When a company raises its own two pillars, customers and suppliers see it. Once they see it, courage and justice have followers. JIAHON is doing this too, imperfectly — but imperfection is no reason not to speak.

References

  1. Saad, G. (2026). Suicidal Empathy: Dying to Be Kind. Broadside Books / HarperCollins. (Provisional Traditional Chinese title 《自殺式同情:失控的善意》, rights agented by Bardon.)
  2. Saad, G. (2020). The Parasitic Mind. Regnery.
  3. Sowell, T. (1995). The Vision of the Anointed. Basic Books.
  4. Campbell, B., & Manning, J. (2018). The Rise of Victimhood Culture. Palgrave Macmillan.
  5. Analects, “Li Ren”: “When you see a worthy person, think of becoming equal to them; when you see an unworthy one, examine yourself within.”
  6. Figures in Table 1 and Figure 2: at least one success in 10 attempts = 1 − (1 − p)¹⁰; expected deals in 100 attempts = 100 × p.
  7. Taiwan’s Police Weapons Use Act, amended on third reading 30 September 2022 and promulgated 19 October 2022; Employment Insurance Act, Article 16.
  8. This article’s summary of the book draws on the publisher’s description and several public reviews, restated in the author’s own words.

Note: This is an opinion article; the cases cited all come from the book and public reports. Comments on institutions and phenomena represent the JIAHON Think Tank’s position and do not constitute accusations against any particular person or organization, nor legal advice.

License: This work is published by JIAHON Group. All rights reserved. Quotation and redistribution are permitted with proper attribution and a link to jiahon.com.tw. Commercial use — including but not limited to paid courses, reports, or consulting services incorporating this content or its frameworks (including “the order of the pillars” and “a single attempt is a dice roll, a life is a probability”) — requires prior written authorization from JIAHON. For commercial licensing, please contact us through our website.

Back to top