中文English

Setting Up a Factory Overseas and Stretched Thin? Jiahon’s Risk Analysis Keeps It From Becoming a Hot Potato

SMT line planning

Taiwanese manufacturers have never stopped expanding overseas. From Southeast Asia to the Middle East, more and more companies choose to build production lines locally, to be close to the market and to spread risk. But when you move a factory thousands of kilometers away, there is one thing that is often found to be unprepared just when something goes wrong — when equipment breaks down, there is nobody who can come and fix it right away.

The fear is not that it breaks, but that it breaks where nobody can deal with it

When a factory in Taiwan has a problem, you call the maker, and an engineer can arrive as soon as the next day. Overseas it is different. Visas, flights, air freight for parts — waiting for someone to arrive may take a week or more. During that time, the line is stopped, the orders keep coming, and the customer is waiting.

This is not pessimism; this is reality.

Jiahon recently helped a customer carry out a complete risk analysis of the auxiliary equipment on its overseas SMT line. The customer’s core request was direct: if equipment has a problem, the people on site must be able to deal with it themselves, without waiting for Taiwan every time.

A systematic breakdown, not telling you to buy one more spare machine

Faced with this need, the easy route is “a full backup set of everything” — buy two of each machine, so if one breaks there is still the other. This logic is not wrong, but the cost is often high enough to put people off, and not every machine is worth treating this way.

Jiahon’s approach is to ask first: if this machine breaks down, what is the real impact?

Taking the 13 pieces of auxiliary equipment in this overseas factory case as an example, the analysis roughly sorted them into three classes by the impact of a failure:

Equipment typeRepresentative equipmentImpact of failureSuggested strategy
Mainly mechanical structure, almost no failure riskStencil tension meter, granite surface plate, feeder calibration fixtureVery lowBuy two sets as redundant backup; low cost, single-point failure risk goes to zero
Has electronic parts, but a simple and effective backup existsSolder paste storage refrigerator, dry cabinet, nozzle cleaning machineMediumPrepare substitute consumables or small substitute equipment in advance; people on site can carry it out after training
A substitute operation is workable; needs a standardized SOPStencil cleaning machine, solder paste mixer, solder paste thawing rackLowManual operation as backup; write the SOP and train in advance, so people can take over immediately in an emergency

Key idea: backup planning does not mean “buy two of everything”. The key is to assess the impact of a failure first, then decide whether to use redundant backup, spare parts and materials, or manual substitution — the cost of the three strategies can differ very widely.

When you meet a machine you have “just one of” while setting up the line: three substitute approaches

When an overseas line has just been set up, many auxiliary machines are bought as a single unit. When that one stops, the whole process after it stops too. The approach in this case was to answer one question first for every machine there is “just one of”: if it stops, what can the site use to stand in? The answers roughly fall into three types:

  • Buy a second set: back up directly what is cheap and does not break. Tools that are mainly mechanical structures, such as the stencil tension meter, granite surface plate and feeder calibration fixture, almost never fail and are not expensive per unit, so keep one more set directly, and the risk of a single-point failure is gone.

  • Switch to simpler substitute equipment or consumables. For equipment that has electronic parts but a simple substitute, prepare the substitute in advance. For example, if the solder paste thawing machine stops, you can switch to a purely physical solder paste first-in-first-out thawing rack; when the dry cabinet fails, there is a substitute that can stand in directly (see example 1 below); if the nozzle cleaning machine stops, switch to a small benchtop ultrasonic cleaner.

  • Switch to manual operation, with the SOP written in advance. For equipment that can be switched to manual operation, such as the stencil cleaning machine and the solder paste mixer, write the manual procedure as an SOP in normal times, train the people, and keep enough cleanroom wipers and wiping paper for manual wiping.

The costs of the three approaches differ a lot: the first costs one more set of tools, the second costs spare parts, and the third costs little more than labor and consumables. Sort out first which type each machine belongs to, and you will not buy two of every machine “just in case”. The suggested approach for each of the 13 machines, item by item, is summarized in “Overseas SMT Line Contingency Plan“.

Low cost, but it has to be thought through in advance

What made this analysis meaningful to the customer was not the spare parts list itself, but that for every item we could say why it is backed up this way, what to do in an emergency, and whether the effect can be relied on. Here are two actual examples:

Example 1: What if the dry cabinet fails?

The initial emergency plan was to put in desiccant and buy household dehumidifiers. It works, but it is not stable enough — household dehumidifiers cannot reach industrial low-humidity requirements, and desiccant is used up fast and needs frequent replacement. Jiahon’s additional suggestion was to keep one or two dehumidifying modules directly: small and easy to replace, they are a really effective backup. Desiccant is just a short-term stopgap and cannot be the main plan.

Example 2: What if the solder paste thawing machine fails?

The electronics of the thawing machine itself are very simple, and it almost never breaks. But even if it really does break, the backup plan is plain: switch to a purely physical “first-in-first-out thawing rack”, with no electronic parts, no failure risk and lower cost; failing that, marking out an area on the workbench and managing it manually with time labels is entirely workable too. Jiahon even suggests: for this kind of equipment, just buy the thawing rack, and you need not worry about potential failures of an electronic thawing machine.

Cost comparison: the travel cost of one engineer flying from Taiwan to an overseas line (flights, food and lodging, expedited visa) often far exceeds the purchase cost of a whole set of spare parts and materials. The return on planning in advance is far higher than on remedies after the fact.

Three core actions of backup planning

A complete contingency plan is not just preparing spare parts; three levels have to be in place at the same time:

Write an SOP for each backup planSet up an emergency supplies storage areaRun regular drills
Bilingual Chinese and English, with pictures and text, posted next to the equipment. In an emergency, people on site do not have to rely on memory — just follow it.Manage spare parts and consumables in one place, with a monthly stock count, so the quantities are sufficient and in usable condition. Every use must be logged and trigger the restocking process.An unannounced drill every quarter or every six months. Letting people get familiar with the process under pressure is what keeps them calm in a real emergency.

Thinking it through before building the factory pays far better than fixing it after something goes wrong

The contingency plan for each machine is, frankly, not complicated — what is complicated is whether someone systematically thinks the problems through in advance, writes the SOPs, prepares the spare parts list and trains the people on site.

This is the kind of work Jiahon does. We do not just help you buy equipment; we help you think the “what ifs” through before you buy, so that the overseas line can respond on its own from the start.

Planning an overseas line? Start from the equipment list and look at the risks together

You are welcome to contact Jiahon; we can help with risk assessment of auxiliary equipment and planning of backup plans.
Contact Jiahon

Also see — related products

The core consumable of the stencil cleaning machine backup plan; essential for manual wiping; overseas lines are advised to keep it in stock.A multi-purpose cleaning consumable for manual wiping of the stencil top side; indispensable for emergencies on overseas lines.SMT consumables, measuring tools and cleanroom equipment from one source; please ask about consolidated purchasing.

© Jiahon Group | jiahon.com.tw

Back to top